IHSH-340-RED - Ultra Heavy Flannel Classic Check Western Shirt - Red
-
@B_OneBomber Welcome to the forum. I have no idea where the suggestions of sizing up come from. The overall fit looks fine to me. The arm length is where I would like it, the overall length is good. If anything, the shoulders/upper back looks a little roomy to me. Did you pick it up in person? Did you try on a size smaller? That would snug it up in these areas, but will possibly come up too short.
-
that's a great fit in my opinion. as good as it gets, and this shirt is wonderful
Thank you! Yeah, I agree, it's a beautiful shirt
-
Size up, no way, you could have some shrinkage and it still not be too small…. Was it a clothing forum
Thanks for the feedback! Seems like after a cold wash it will be perfect. That is what I was hoping for. I wanted a little room for shrinkage just in case. I have another IH shirt (5 oz Chambray Workshirt) and its the same size. Not sure how consistent IH is with its sizing in the different shirt offerings, but they seem fairly similar. I also compared the measurements pretty meticulously to two other shirts I have and selected my size based on that. I pretty much got what I expected. I was very pleased with how accurate the measurements were on your site. I appreciate that.
It was raw denim forum haha. I think you can probably guess which one :o :o :o Was the first time I ever posted a fit pic. I guess I shouldn't be surprised what you get when you ask the internet an opinion about something like this. I was a little surprised at the amount shade thrown at IH shirts. Main complaint was the price ???
-
@B_OneBomber Welcome to the forum. I have no idea where the suggestions of sizing up come from. The overall fit looks fine to me. The arm length is where I would like it, the overall length is good. If anything, the shoulders/upper back looks a little roomy to me. Did you pick it up in person? Did you try on a size smaller? That would snug it up in these areas, but will possibly come up too short.
I got this online from IH Germany so I was not able to try on a smaller size. Based on the chest and length measurements though, I don't think the small would work. I'm thinking after one home wash and a little shrinkage, this will be perfect. Thanks for your feedback!
-
Change nothing [mention]B_OneBomber [/mention][emoji106] very nice fit. Very nice shirt.
Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk
Thank you!
-
@B_OneBomber Just found the forum and spent the last 10 minutes reading the comments regarding the fit of your shirt. All over the place re: sizing, fit, and finish. Most of the time I was just shaking my head in a general disbelief.
Not going to bash but I think the age demographic and audience is much different than you will find here. The most important thing is that you’re happy and my $.02 is that you’ve done a good job.
-
I don't consider Reddit a proper forum, and neither should you. I saw your post yesterday and the replies were ridiculous. As Giles said, if anything I would think about sizing down depending how trim you like the fit. With the shirt you currently own, it looks great and you have room for some shrinkage to occur to dial it in perfectly!
-
@B_OneBomber my opinion is worth no more than anyone else’s but some thoughts:
it looks good to me
@goosehd is (obviously) right - if you’re happy then the fit’s good
fit and build quality are different beasties - we have probably all got our hands on something that’s gorgeous but just doesn’t work for us (not that this applies in this case)
value for money is entirely subjective - again if you’re happy then everything’s good
I get the need for a second opinion (and I’ve asked in the past) but only you know how you feel - if you’re happy … -
The current size looks good. With a bit of shrink from a wash and creases in the elbow area the sleeves will be slightly shorter and then the fit will be perfect.
Somebody save me the trouble and tell me who’s on this redit forum. Skateboarders and LA gangsters from the 90s?
-
I think the fit would be even better with a hot wash, but it looks great as is. Could not imagine sizing up. I know some people tend to wear things a few sizes larger than what would be a 'regular' fit because it may or may not be trendy to wear very oversized street fashion recently.
-
What’s funny to me is that just a few years ago everyone would be saying, “Size down!”, or “Size down two!”. Slim fits were so in for a long time that I feel like everyone was squeezing themselves into fits like sausage casing. I guess that ship has sailed? Good riddance, as for me comfort is key, but I think your fit is on point for this one, and you can wear and wash without worry.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Welcome @B_OneBomber You def nailed the right size–it looks great. I've been building a little IH collection starting with denim items and eventually moving on to fannel and some knitwear/accessories. The pattern on this shirt is amazing. I went Wasbash this season instead of a fannel and this shirt almost makes me regret my decision ;P
I dipped my toes in another forum (named below) and did not find the information very helpful, or even accurate; not to mention, a general tone of judgment as opposed a sharing in a hobby/ passion type thing.
Enjoy your excellent flannel!!
@sabergirl makes a good point here too. I'll add that buying things 'sausage casing' tight does not generally lead to owing something for the long haul IMO. You'll eventually only going reach for the comfortable garments in your closet anyway.
-
i somehow missed this one, but what a beautiful shirt that is…can't buy it right now, but i will be definitely keep it on my wish list. just wonderful.
-
I truly appreciate all the feedback. I am loving this shirt and wear it often. I gave it a 30 degree wash and hang dry and it shrunk a bit, and it fits great. It's very warm and cozy for the cold winter months here in Germany.
I didn't want to call out the other forum specifically as to try to avoid perpetuating any negativity. This shirt and all the other Iron Heart products I own just bring so much joy and I'd like to highlight that above all else
